Mesothelioma Treatments: Curative Surgery -
Pleurectomy-Decortication
Pleurectomy-decortication is a compound
surgery, featuring a parietal pleurectomy and a decortication of the lung
with a full resection of visceral pleura. During a pleurectomy-decortication
both pleurae will be removed and it is likely that extrapleural tissue
structures, such as parts of the diaphragm and the pericardium, will be
removed as well. It is commonly deployed for patients
presenting with the earliest stages of the disease, although the individual
procedures can be deployed for palliative purposes as well. To learn more about
these palliative uses, please read:
Pleurectomy-decortication is one of the two major
curative surgeries performed for the treatment of pleural
mesothelioma.
Extrapleural pneumonectomy (EPP) is the other major
surgery.
Pleurectomy-Decortication – Overview of the Procedure
Pleurectomy-decortication (PD) is considered radical surgery due to the
extensive amount of tissue resection attempted during the procedure and the
highly invasive techniques necessary to complete the operation. Patients who
undergo pleurectomy-decortication face an extended recovery period and
serious complications are not uncommon, but the procedure has been used to
extend survival time in large numbers of
mesothelioma patients.
During the earliest phases of the operation,
pleurectomy-decortication and extrapleural pneumonectomy
proceed in a similar manner. The procedure requires an
extended
posterolateral thoracotomy for entry into the
interior of chest. The extensive incision is done to give
the surgeon greater exposure to the patient’s thorax. In
some cases, the 6th rib may be removed to facilitate entry
into the pleural cavity. When the surgeon reaches this area,
he or she will then begin the actual resection.
The parietal pleura and its surrounding areas will be the
surgeon’s initial target. The diaphragm is likely to be
removed, as is the pericardium if it cannot be easily
separated from the parietal pleura or if it shows any signs
of malignancy.
The surgeon will then begin what is probably the most
difficult part of the operation: decortication of the lung
and full resection of the visceral pleura. A number of
issues can affect the degree to which the two pleurae can be
separated and the visceral pleura cleanly and safely removed
from the lung, so the surgeon will carefully analyze the
status of these tissue structures and will proceed in a
manner that maximizes the potential for full removal of the
visceral pleura and the achievement of a
macroscopically-complete resection. Any surgical
manipulation of the visceral pleura raises the possibility
for damage to the underlying lung, so the surgeon must
balance the desire to achieve full resection with the
present status of the lung and the potential for attendant
lung damage.
After the surgeon has completed the operation, he or she
must then begin the reconstructive processes which are
necessary to ensure proper lung function. If the
diaphragm or the pericardium has been removed, the surgeon
will reconstruct the respective structure using a mesh fiber
that will achieve a similar function as the original
structure.
During the procedure, the surgeon will remove adjacent
lymph nodes for post-operative
staging analysis. The lymph
nodes will be packaged and identified, and then sent to a
pathologist for analysis. This information will inform
whatever
follow-up treatments that the patient may undergo.
Once all of the tissues have been removed, and the
diaphragm and pericardium reconstructed if needed, the
surgeon will begin the exit procedure. Complications are not
uncommon with pleurectomy-decortication, so the surgeon will
check to make sure that everything has been properly
completed and is in the appropriate state. Drainage tubes
will be inserted in various locations to ensure fluid
dissemination from the pleural cavity and surrounding areas.
This should enable proper lung expansion and will aid in
patient recovery. Should everything be order, the surgeon
will step backward through each of the steps made during the
initial approach, reconstructing and reattaching tissues
that had to be cut during entry and closing up incisions as
he or she goes along.
The patient will then be moved into the Intensive Care
Unit for a few days of monitoring before starting on his or
her rehabilitation program. Pleurectomy-decortication and
thoracotomy are major operations and feature significant
post-operative healing, so it is important for patients to
take their recovery slowly.
Pleurectomy-Decortication – Treatment Considerations
As in all forms of radical surgery, serious complications can occur
during pleurectomy-decortication, or the hours and days immediately
following it. Damage to the lung from manipulation of the visceral pleura is
always a concern, as are complications related to blood loss, breathing
obstructions and the reconstruction of the diaphragm and pericardium.
However, despite the possibility for complications, most surgeons feel that
candidates for curative surgery should undergo the operation to
maximize their potential for long-term survival. Most of the complications
associated with pleurectomy-decortication are now fairly well-known, so even
if surgeons aren’t able to prevent their occurrence, they can plan
for their possibility and will be ready to adjust should one
appear.
Historically, pleurectomy-decortication has demonstrated
lower perioperative and postoperative mortality rates and
morbidity figures than has extrapleural pneumonectomy.
Pleurectomy-Decortication vs. Extrapleural Pneumonectomy
A recurrent question in
mesothelioma treatment
is to what extent
pleurectomy-decortication should be chosen over extrapleural pneumonectomy
and what it “means” to choose one procedure over the other.
Many people have thought that the treatments were relatively interchangeable
and that pleurectomy-decortication was the “better” option for the
treatment of
pleural mesothelioma because it is
a less radical procedure that preserves
the lung, while extrapleural pneumonectomy was the “worse” option because of
the removal of the long and the extended recovery time.
Studies have generally concluded that the two procedures
have different domains of application and are most effective
for patients in different stages of the disease. Pleurectomy-decortication is generally
performed on patients who present with locally-contained
mesothelioma that only evidences a sparse advancement into
adjacent tissues, while extrapleural pneumonectomy is
most-often used for patients who exhibit more extensive
spread of the disease or for those who have enrolled in a
treatment protocol that specifies EPP as one modality in a
multimodal approach to the disease.
The key to all mesothelioma surgeries is to achieve a
macroscopically-complete resection, so the procedure that
can best achieve such a resection is in fact “the better”
procedure for an individual patient. During the disease’s
earliest stages, a pleurectomy-decortication may be all that
is needed to achieve a macroscopically-complete resection.
For patients who are lucky enough to be diagnosed with
limited tumor burden, pleurectomy-decortication is likely to
be a good option. However, for patients who present with
more extensive tumor infiltration—the norm with the majority
of
mesothelioma diagnoses—extrapleural pneumonectomy will
the surgery of choice because it is more likely to achieve a
macroscopically-complete resection than is a
pleurectomy-decortication.
In many instances, a surgeon will not know which
procedure will be performed upon beginning thoracotomy. If
preoperative imaging scans show only sparse tissue
infiltration, the surgeon may assume that
pleurectomy-decortication will be performed, but if, upon
entry into the pleural cavity, it is discovered that CT or
MRI failed to disclose the full extent of the malignancy, the
surgeon will likely attempt an extrapleural pneumonectomy.
Although less likely, the opposite could be true as well:
the surgeon may begin thoracotomy with the assumption of
extensive tissue infiltration and, therefore, the
performance of an EPP, but upon entry into the pleural
cavity, the surgeon may see a smaller area of infiltration
and a PD will be performed instead.
Pleurectomy-Decortication – Conclusion
Pleurectomy-Decortication is one of the major surgeries employed
for the treatment of pleural mesothelioma. Pleurectomy-decortication is
performed on patients in the earliest stages of mesothelioma, when tissue
infiltration is still relatively contained within a smaller surface area.
Extrapleural pneumonectomy has probably been performed more than
pleurectomy-decortication has been performed, so most of the results that
relate to the multimodal treatment of the disease are reporting on EPP-based
treatment protocols. However, successful pleurectomy-decortication should
still achieve the same basic goal as a successful EPP—that is, a
macroscopically-complete resection—so the use of
pleurectomy-decortication within a multimodal treatment protocol is likely to achieve
longer median survival than is a strictly palliative protocol or one that
only features single modality therapy.
Related Information: Mesothelioma &
Surgery
For more information related to the surgical treatment of mesothelioma, please read the following:
|